Yes, but with enough improvements to make it worth you time. Or if you just prefer the Medieval Fantasy theme.
At its dead heart, Zombicide Black Plague (ZBP from now on) is pretty much your baseline Zombicide. You wander around the map looking for better weapons and gear, kill a bunch of zombies, and achieve the missions goals. Or die trying. Still a fast moving, fun game for 1-6 players.
What ZBP does better than the first versions is pretty much everything, just in small amounts. The new plastic player trays are fantastic and make keeping all your stuff and stats easily accessible. Plus, they have added a body slot to put armor or some gear. The color coded plastic rings to go around your player mini was a good idea, instead of trying to figure out whose figure was light aqua, and whose was seafoam.
The rules have been cleaned up a little bit, but still could have benefitted from an editing pass, some of the wording is clunky, but still understandable after a read or three.
The Zombvivors are gone, which I feel is for the best, I was never a fan of the way they were implemented. It is much easier to heal your characters now, so player eliminations will not be as frequent. The Necromancer is a nice addition as a bad guy, but I kinda wanted it as a "boss monster" rather than a special wandering monster. Still adds nice flavor, they just show up too often.
The miniatures themselves are very nice sculpts, with a good variety of poses for the undead. I was a little let down in the lack of variation in the weapons, but I guess there is only so much they felt like doing. One weapon's stats in particular, The Great Sword, makes no sense to us, so we will work out some kind of house rule for it.
There are magic spells in the game, but anyone can use them, which is good from a game standpoint, but a bit jarring from a typical fantasy setting. "Oh sure, we all use magic, it's easy!" I guess to be in the Fantasy Hero Union you have to get qualified on spell usage.
There is a tidal wave of expansions coming for this game, we got in on the Kickstarter, so an nearly unusable number of new heroes and cards will be here soon as well as the first expansion which adds werewolves. That is the big question for us: How many fantasy monsters are they going to add? How fast will it make the game an overencumbered mess? Maybe they will keep things separated: Zombie missions, Werewolf missions, Troll missions, etc. I hope so, or it will turn into too much of a good thing like the original Zombicide did if you weren't very careful.
All in all, I recommend it. It is a fun co-op zombie slaying game with swords and spells.
Eight decapitations out ten.
Go Roll Some Dice
And Chop up some Undead